Saw a lot of media coverage about T-Mobile’s introduction of the G1 handset. Â I’ve watched several demos and I’m not really sure what I think of the handset yet. Â Its certainly not got the wow factor that I had after seeing the introduction of the iPhone. Â Maybe the missing piece was the Steve’s reality distortion field. Â
The software looks compelling in the demos that I have seen, but lacks the polish of the iPhone. Â Google has done a good job creating a platform, though I’ve seen some outstanding UI concepts that are not integrated into this particular handset. What seems to be lacking is the cohesiveness that makes the iPhone great. Â The UI looks a little disjointed with the main menu which scrolls in and then the ability to dock widgets and app icons on the “desktop.” Â I really don’t know what else to call it – home screen maybe. Â
Surprisingly, the capacity of the G1 is very minimal – sitting at only 1Gb of storage. Â That is a major limiting factor, but reflects the fact that the G1 isn’t an all-in-one, convergence device. Â Its just a smart phone with internet. Â That is the iPhone’s biggest competative advantage, but then I don’t think we’re seeing Google squaring off the device against Apple. Â Apple has turned out to be a great partner which showcases many of Google’s online products within the iPhone, so the G1 isn’t going head to head with the iPod capabilities of the iPhone for sure. Â
AppleInsider has a great piece about the differences and goes much more into depth comparing the devices – worth a read for sure…